Browsed by
Month: March 2024

“Blessed are those who have not seen”

“Blessed are those who have not seen”

Renaissance painting by Piero della Francesca, “Resurrection,” c.1463, Italy
“Resurrection” by Piero della Francesca, c. 1463.

The dramatic stories of Holy Week lead to the equally dramatic stories of Easter, celebrated this Sunday. If you read my blog post from last week, you might be thinking, “So, I suppose you’re going to say the Easter story is made up, also.” And, of course, the short answer is, “Yes.” But something obviously happened and that’s what we need to explore first. Then, we can turn to the next question, “So what? What meaning does Easter still have for us today?”

As with the stories of Holy Week, we must start by understanding the sources of the Easter stories. For the Easter morning story of the empty tomb, the answer seems to be the gospel of Mark, written approximately forty years after Jesus’ death. Paul, writing about twenty years earlier, never mentions this tradition. Nor do any other non-gospel writings in the New Testament.

I wrote last week that Mark was the first to create a “Jesus story.” Jesus’ life ended with his crucifixion but for Mark, of course, the story of Jesus went on as the risen Lord and Messiah. I believe that it was to convey that truth that led Mark to conclude his gospel with the story of the discovery of the empty tomb.

For many Christians today, the astonishing thing about Mark’s Easter story (which is the Easter gospel this year) is that the risen Jesus makes no appearance. Three women go to the tomb where Jesus had been laid and find the stone “door” rolled away. Inside, they meet “a young man dressed in a white robe” who tells them that Jesus is not here because he has been raised. He directs them to “tell his disciples and Peter” to go to Galilee where they will see him again. They don’t exactly follow his instructions.

So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them, and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.

And that’s it. No Jesus, no disciples, no joyous reunion. Scholars have made many attempts to explain this odd ending to Mark’s gospel. Perhaps the most likely is that in the wake of the destruction of the Roman-Jewish War, Mark is declaring the Jerusalem/Judean chapter of the Jesus movement to be over. Galilee, symbolizing the bridge between the Jewish and gentile worlds, is now where the risen Jesus is to be “seen.”

It’s obvious that there was dissatisfaction with Mark’s ending. Some manuscripts of Mark have other endings where Jesus does appear, but these are now recognized as additions by later Christian scribes. Matthew and Luke, of course, add appearances of the risen Jesus to Mark’s story (on which their gospels are based), but they are not consistent with each other (or with John).

What this means, then, is that the first account of a physical Jesus appearing on Easter morning is not written until at least a half-century after Jesus’ death. It’s impossible to imagine that such astonishing events would not have been immediately and repeatedly spoken about. The only conclusion, then, is that those stories were first created decades later as part of the early church’s developing proclamation.

So what did happen on Easter? Was Jesus raised from the dead? That answer is (and has always been) in the letters of Paul. His most explicit statement is in 1 Corinthians 15.

For I handed on to you as of first importance what I in turn had received: that Christ … appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have died. Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles. Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.

The Greek word translated “appeared” is one commonly used in the ancient world to refer to experiences in visions or dreams, which were taken seriously and meaningfully. Paul’s own discussion of his experience, and even Luke’s account in Acts of Paul’s Damascus road experience, support such an interpretation. What is significant is that Paul implies his experience of the risen Jesus, late as it was, was of the same type as that of the disciples before him.

Other than Paul’s list, we have no stories of these appearances, not even to Peter (“Cephas”), who was supposedly the first to see the risen Jesus. It’s also possible that the first such experiences were actually among Jesus’ women followers, as the gospels seem to imply. Visions and appearances are subjective experiences, however, and this may explain the element of doubt in the gospel accounts.

In Luke, the women’s empty tomb story is met with skepticism by the disciples. “But these words seemed to them an idle tale, and they did not believe them.” And even when Jesus appears to the disciples themselves, there is uncertainty. “Yet for all their joy they were still disbelieving and wondering.” In Matthew, Jesus appears to the disciples in Galilee with similar results. “When they saw him, they worshiped him, but they doubted.”

If the Easter experience was that of seeing a physically resurrected Jesus, this doubting makes no sense. But if instead “Easter” was a series of people saying (over a period of weeks, months, or even years, as in the case of Paul) that they had a vision of Jesus alive and in heaven, then the doubting is easily understood. “You say you saw what? I don’t believe it.”

The resurrection story in John’s gospel may point as this problem most directly. He seems to try to preserve the disciples’ reputation by attributing all the doubting to the hapless Thomas. Absent for Jesus’ appearance on Sunday night, when the disciples tell him, “We have seen the Lord,” Thomas responds, “I will not believe,” unless he, too, can see the marks of Jesus’ crucifixion on his body.

When Jesus appears again a week later, Thomas gets his wish and believes. Jesus’ response to Thomas’s confession sums up the early church’s dilemma, and that of the church ever since: What if you haven’t had a vision of Jesus?

“Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe.”

The appearance of a physically raised Jesus makes for good stories. But to take it beyond storytelling only leads to theological conundrums (e.g. where did his raised body go?) and distracts from the real issue of faith: What does it mean now to “see Jesus?”

To return to Paul, he asserts his experience of the risen Jesus (“Have I not seen Jesus our Lord?”) to justify his claim to be an apostle. He never says people should believe in Jesus because of his experience of seeing him. Where is Jesus now? “You are the body of Christ” he writes. Christ now lives in him and in every disciple, who bear in their lives the “fruits” of Christ’s Spirit: “love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, generosity, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control.”

An obsession with the ancient gospel Easter stories is a way of avoiding the challenge of faith now. “If the Easter stories aren’t true, then there’s nothing to believe in!” Nonsense. Christianity isn’t about believing in incredible stories from two thousand years ago. If Christianity has any value, it is in faith that the God we encounter in the story of Jesus is just as real today.

The truth of that is not obvious, of course. That’s why it’s called faith. Yet that faith is not affirmed by closing our eyes tight and repeating “I believe. I believe.” Rather, faith is affirmed by taking the risk of living by it and experiencing its truth within us and in the world and people around us. Only then may we be able to respond like Mary Magdalene, “I have seen the Lord.”

The week that wasn’t

The week that wasn’t

Salvador Dali Christ of St. John of the CrossIt’s been my practice to write a series of seasonal blog posts trying to make sense of the events depicted during Holy Week and Easter. Did they happen? If they didn’t, what did happen? And what does it all mean? I’m going to take another stab at this, using some past writings but also updates based on new things I’ve learned and thoughts I’ve had.

This Sunday is Palm Sunday, in some places also known as Sunday of the Passion. At most churches palm branches will be distributed to worshipers who will be encouraged to wave them when the gospel story is read. They may also process with them in or around the church building. Liturgically oriented churches may also have a second gospel reading of all or part of the Passion story. Speaking parts may be given to various members of the congregation.

This certainly is the most dramatic Sunday of the liturgical year. People usually get into it, and it’s kind of fun. Well, at least the palm part is. Things get dark pretty quickly in the Passion reading. In any case, this liturgy is usually thought of as a kind of historical reenactment of the last week of Jesus’ life. Thus, many worshipers would likely be surprised, and perhaps dismayed, to learn that most biblical scholars today (excluding fundamentalists, of course) regard little of it that way. “You mean someone made it all up?” Well, many people were likely involved but, basically, yes.

The biggest problem with reconstructing the life of Jesus is that we simply have so little reliable information. The earliest writings after Jesus’ death (about twenty years later) are the letters of Paul, and he tells us nothing about the historic Jesus because he didn’t know him. Nor are the gospels eye-witness accounts. In fact, we have nothing in writing from anyone who knew or even saw Jesus.

Of the four canonical gospels, Mark often gets short shrift. Yet it was Mark’s anonymous author who was the first to create a “story of Jesus.” And “create” is the operative word. Mark was written forty years after Jesus’ death and shortly after the disastrous conclusion of the first Jewish-Roman war. Jerusalem was in ruins and the temple destroyed. Countless thousands were dead and thousands more displaced.

Imagine, then, trying to write, from hundreds of miles away, the history of a person who lived decades earlier in a place that has essentially been destroyed, without any witnesses and without any modern means of research. It couldn’t be done. But that’s not what the gospels are trying to be. As Mark says in its first verse, the book is a telling of the “good news” of Jesus Christ. Thus, it is a literary sermon, not a carefully investigated biography of Jesus of Nazareth.

The difficulty in reconstructing the life of Jesus isn’t surprising then. Scholars today agree that Jesus came from the furthest margins of society: a Jewish peasant who lived in the backwater of a backwater: the region of Galilee on the fringe of Rome’s despised province of Judea. To observers at the time, Jesus would have been one of a dime-a-dozen wandering mystics, teachers, holy men, and miracle workers common to the region.

This is why the biblical events of Holy Week are now seen as literary fiction. The basic plot is certainly plausible. For whatever reason, Jesus went to Jerusalem, got himself in trouble with Roman authorities by creating a commotion in the temple, which then led to his arrest and execution. But someone as insignificant as Jesus would never have rated the tumult or attention depicted in the gospels.

The details of that story are now viewed as the product of early church evangelists and writers. Their narrative source, rather than eyewitnesses, was primarily the Hebrew Bible, the Christian Old Testament. Following a long and respected religious tradition, biblical stories were used to provide the interpretive framework for this new religious event: the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ.

The question for us is whether the meaning and importance they saw (and the gospels themselves have differing views on that) is what we would now see or value. To me, there are at least two major problems, and both contribute to the overwrought nature of the gospels’ telling of the Passion story.

The first is the anti-Judaism present to some degree in each of the gospels, and especially in the Passion stories. This problem has been recognized for a long time. Since the Holocaust, various attempts have been made to remedy it, though none have been satisfactory.

Biblical scholarship has cast doubt on what role (if any) Jewish religious authorities would have had in Jesus’ death. Even the gospels strain to come up with a plausible connection, primarily because their own accounts of Jesus’ ministry in Galilee give them little to work with. It is much more likely that Jesus was executed by Roman authorities because he did something which they considered a threat to public order. The table-turning incident in the temple is one possibility.

So why the hostility to Judaism in the gospels? Because they were written at the time of the split between church and synagogue. Divorces can be angry, messy affairs and this one certainly was. That most Jews did not embrace Jesus as the Christ became an awkward embarrassment for the early church. If Jesus really was the Jewish messiah, then why did most Jews not accept him? Thus, began the meme of the messiah’s rejection by his own people, portrayed most dramatically in the fiction of Jesus’ Jerusalem trial.

The second problem is the theological interpretation of Jesus’ death as a sacrifice for humanity’s sin, like the animal sacrifices made in the temple. This makes little if any sense to modern people. More importantly, it makes God appear as an ancient bloodthirsty ogre. While some fundamentalists still revel in this image, most people find it bizarre and repulsive.

The obvious rebuttal to that portrayal is Jesus himself. This supposed divine need for justice and judgment that sent Jesus to the cross is noticeably absent in Jesus’ own life. Forgiveness and compassion are the heart of his life and ministry and his teaching about God.

As this has been rediscovered in recent years, Jesus’ death has been re-framed as the ultimate expression of that compassion and selflessness.  If Jesus’ death is saving it is because it inspires people to the life of love that is our human calling and true nature. Jesus did not die “for our sins” but because of sin. God is not “satisfied” by Jesus’ death but heartbroken.

Can the gospels’ Passion narratives be saved? The disinterest in Good Friday and the resistance to imposing the Passion reading on Palm Sunday are strong indications of how even average Christians feel. The church needs to pay attention. The symbol of the cross is important and powerful and shouldn’t be lost. Ironically, however, the stories that have swirled around it for centuries are now preventing us from seeing it.

A good person

A good person

Coach Matt Lynch and teamAt the end of Steven Spielberg’s Saving Private Ryan, the title character, now an elderly veteran, visits the American military cemetery in Normandy, France. He finds the grave of the Army Captain who led the mission to save his life and remembers his last, dying words to him: “Earn this.” Meaning, live a life worthy of the sacrifices made to save you. Remembering that harrowing scene decades later, Ryan, in tears, turns to his wife and says, “Tell me I’ve led a good life. Tell me I’m a good man.”

What does it mean to lead a good life, to be a good person? I thought of those questions reading a recent, powerful story in the New York Times: This Man Turned the Worst Job in College Basketball Into a Slam Dunk. “This man” is Matt Lynch, 33, head coach of the men’s basketball team at University of South Carolina Salkehatchie, a small regional school about an hour west of Charleston.

Salkehatchie is likely the opposite of your image of “elite university.” When Lynch arrived, its basketball program hardly existed. In the eight months before his appointment, four coaches had been hired and quit. The starting salary was $38,000, there were no other staff, no recruiting budget, and no players. But Lynch was undaunted.

With the help of his mother and siblings, Lynch renovated the dilapidated locker room. Connections led to new uniforms donated by Nike. To find prospective players, he traveled thousands of miles and watched hours of games online. The result was a roster literally from around the world. And after one season Salkehatchie basketball has a winning record and a chance to be in the playoffs.

The reason this story was in the Times, however, is not Lynch’s remarkable drive or accomplishments, but because he is gay.

According to Outsports, the website that chronicles L.G.B.T.Q. athletes, there had never been a publicly gay men’s head coach in any of the North American major professional leagues, nor in college football or men’s basketball until Lynch.

There was no way for Lynch to know if being gay would affect his job prospects, but it remained a question in the back of his mind — even for a job that was within his reach.

“If I was going to get a head coaching job, I knew it was going to be at a place that needed to be built,” said Lynch, who came out publicly nearly four years ago in an essay for Outsports…. “All I ever wanted was an opportunity. The way I looked at it was this may be a bad job, but it’s my bad job. You’ve got to make the big time where you are.”

Matt Lynch understands that being a good coach means being a good person. Not only does he guide his team in playing basketball, but he also guides his players in being human. As he told one family, “There’s nothing sexy about Salkehatchie. But if you come here, you’re going to be a better man, a better student and a better athlete.” And “being better” would extend to all areas of life.

Lynch made no assurances to parents about playing time or winning. But he made two promises: that they would know how to change a flat tire and properly knot a tie.

Thus far, being gay in a small town in the deep South has not been a problem. Nor has it been in coaching his team, where his humanness and openness have only been an asset.

Since players arrived in late August, Lynch has addressed his sexual orientation with the team once — when he hosted a September retreat at his house in Wilmington, N.C. On their last night, the team sat around a bonfire in the backyard….

He told the players he did not need their acceptance — that it had taken nearly 30 years to accept himself. “He’s not afraid to open himself up to us, which is a big positive,” said Darcy Pares, a guard from Port Macquarie, Australia. “We might not like him some days at practice, we might not like him when he wakes us up early to go to the weight room, but we know he’s doing it because he really cares about us.”

While the reaction in the comments to this “feel good” story was overwhelmingly positive, I wondered about how Matt Lynch would otherwise be evaluated in today’s culture. He has thrown himself into a job with no prestige and that, by most standards, pays a pittance. I recently watched a series of on-the-street interviews with undergrads at Harvard. Upon graduation, all expected jobs in major financial or technology companies, paying six-figure salaries. No doubt, their family and friends would be very proud of them. But what if they decided to follow a Matt Lynch type path?

From this story, there can be no doubt that Lynch could have found success in any number of more lucrative careers. But this has been his dream, and he’s followed it. In following that dream, just as in his coming out, he has decided to be true to himself. Doing so takes both encouragement and courage.

One of Jesus’ more perplexing and paradoxical teachings was that we must lose our life in order to find it. I think the life Jesus wants us to lose is the life we think we are supposed to live, the person we think we are supposed to be. We pick up those ideas and images in all sorts of places, especially family, school, religion, and the media. Yet deep within all of us is also an image of our self waiting to be discovered and allowed to flourish.

“Have I been a good person?” Often, we think the measure of that is whether we have made some Mother Theresa-like sacrifices. But I think the real measure is whether we have been the person we know we truly are. In making that choice, Matt Lynch has not only become the coach he felt called to be, but he is also showing the true meaning of being a good person, to his players and to everyone around him.

Church optional

Church optional

Pictured here are Tim and Kathy Johnson, sitting at their kitchen table. Just four years ago, that space held the communion table of Zion Lutheran Church in Benedict, Nebraska. The Johnsons bought and remodeled the building when the church closed. At one time, they were members of Zion. Their son was married there, and grandchildren have been baptized there. Now it’s their home. Here “a house full of memories” has whole new meaning.

The Johnsons’ experience is part of an excellent report in the local Nebraska journal, Flatwater Free Press. Of course, the story of church closures is a national, and even international, one. The regional focus of this article makes the story more personal and more poignant. I was a pastor in Nebraska for several years and can easily imagine the towns and congregations mentioned here.

Nebraska has been what you might call “church country.” I often heard of small towns with multiple congregations of the same denomination. That’s all changing. Some of this, of course, is due to shifting populations as rural and small-town people move to the cities and suburbs. But surveys show that the remaining residents are just as likely to have little or no religious involvement as their urban counterparts.

The Flatwater piece shows that the decline of Christianity is not just about individuals but also communities. A Canadian agency recently declared it a national emergency that so many historic church buildings are being abandoned across that country. Anyone who has traveled to Europe is aware how many church buildings have essentially become museums, even if a small worshiping congregation remains. Many others, as in this Nebraska story, have been converted to some other purpose: houses, condos, B&Bs, stores, galleries, restaurants, bars, gyms, etc.

But not every church building is convertible or worth saving. Some are on land that is too valuable to retain the original building. In Florida, where I just moved from, the closure of a downtown Miami Lutheran church resulted in a multi-million-dollar sale, with the proceeds going to a synod ministry development fund.

The church closures in Flatwater’s report span the denominational spectrum: Baptist, Methodist, Lutheran, Roman Catholic. Also included are the now familiar but still stunning numbers on nationwide religious decline. A ten-year increase in those saying they rarely if ever attended worship, from 43% to 56%. A twenty-year decline in median worship attendance, from 137 to 65. This latter figure goes a long way in explaining the closure of congregations, and why the trend will continue. Increasingly congregations simply can’t afford to maintain their buildings, and/or don’t have enough volunteers to maintain their organizations.

Are congregations essential to Christianity? Many probably can’t imagine it any other way. Yet there have always been Christians who lived where churches were not available. And few, if any, other religions are as congregation oriented as Christianity. Some have shrines and temples, but worshipers aren’t necessarily “members” of them. Many Jews have only a nominal relationship with a synagogue, yet annually attend high holy day services and faithfully light Shabbat candles at home.

One of my interpretations of the recent “great de-churching” is that it has been a rejection of corporate worship. When people leave Christianity, in practical terms, it means they stop “going” to church. I still think that is true but perhaps that’s too narrow a perspective. Perhaps leaving organized religion is really a rejection of belonging to a congregation.

In my experience, Christians often have a romanticized image of their churches, viewing them more favorably than is warranted. Such responses usually come from the active core who worship often, sing in the choir, participate in church organizations, volunteer for committees and governing boards, etc. For that reason, they usually know each other and often count such people among their friends. Yet they are always a minority.

My last congregation had a vibrant and celebrated coffee and fellowship time after Sunday worship. I joked that we had a coffee hour preceded by a worship service. Yet fellowship time participants were only half the story. Each week after worship, I stood at the door shaking the hands of at least as many heading to their cars to leave. Most of these were largely unknown to those getting their cake and coffee.

Every church I have known has members who declare, “We’re so friendly here.” Yet those same congregations have other members who will say, “No one ever talks to me.” When I started in ministry, denominations were in a push to make their congregations more welcoming, especially to visitors. Many churches sprouted big “Welcome Place” banners or put something similar on their signs. Yet to the end of my ministry, it was still common to hear stories of people visiting other congregations where no one said a word to them.

Church leaders have a habit of “whipping the crew until attitudes improve.” Why don’t people sing? Why won’t people read their Bible? Why don’t people volunteer to help? Why aren’t people more friendly? Each question leads to new programs and challenging sermons to bring about the desired change, usually to no avail.

I think congregations will be what they will be, and often that won’t be so great. They will tend towards being cliquish and self-absorbed. There will always be a few who want to run things. Many will never get enough attention for their needs or recognition for their accomplishments. Brick and mortar and landscaping will usually be prioritized over human needs because people want to be “proud” of their church and want something tangible to point to: “See what we did?”

In other words, congregations tend to behave just like any other organization. And for many, that’s just what they’re trying to get away from, or at least don’t need more of. They’ve had their fill of committee and planning meetings, budgets and fund raising, cleaning and maintenance, squabbles and conflict resolution. Even that holiest of gatherings, corporate worship, is more than many can bear given the prevalence of mediocre music, mediocre preaching, and mediocre spaces, plus all the inevitable challenges of being with people in an enclosed space, multiplied now in this pandemic time.

What is Christianity? What does it mean to be a Christian? For a growing number today, “belonging to a church” is no longer the obvious or necessary answer. Most clergy and active laity can’t wrap their heads around this. I think they better learn how. This trend isn’t going away.

Amid the Nazi horrors, and near the end of his life, German theologian and martyr, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, speculated about the need for “religionless Christianity.” He was responding to the mediocrity of German churches and the passivity of their memberships in the face of Nazi oppression and atrocities. Bonhoeffer had come to realize that belonging to a church had little effect on how people thought or behaved.

“But when you pray, go into your own room, shut your door and pray to your Father privately.” Matthew 6:6, J. B. Phillips

Jesus was ambivalent, if not outright hostile, to the organized religion of his day. Whenever he went to the temple or synagogue, there was always a row. The early church’s biggest problem was that Jesus had laid no plans for a new religion. Perhaps those wannabe church leaders missed his point. As the saying goes, “Jesus came preaching the kingdom, but what we got was the church.”