Browsed by
Month: May 2024

God has left the building

God has left the building

Intoned in a dramatic voice (by lead actor Kelsey Grammer), many of the episodes of the long running TV comedy, Frasier, concluded with the announcement, “Frasier has left the building.” If he had known the phrase, the iconoclastic 19th century German philosopher, Frederick Nietzsche, might have used it and declared, “God has left the building.” Instead, he famously (or infamously) said, “God is dead … and we have killed him.”

This Sunday is Trinity Sunday. It is an odd “feast day” because it is the only one dedicated to a doctrine. The Trinity has been argued about throughout church history. The meaning of it has never been clearly stated, so that Jews and Muslims both view it as a polytheistic heresy. Nearly every group that has separated from orthodox Christianity has done so, at least in part, over rejecting the Trinity.

Nonetheless, century after century, the church has clung to the Trinity like a life preserver. But as is always the case when we need to rise to a new level of maturity, it’s time for the church to let it go, and swim.

Typically, the problem with the Trinity has been with “persons” two and three: Jesus, as the Son of God, and the Holy Spirit. How could the human Jesus be divine? How can the Holy Spirit be a separate divine entity? But I don’t think that’s the real problem. The “problem” is actually with the first person, God the Father, because he’s the one that’s “left the building.”

When I was in seminary in the late 1970s, there was great controversy over “God language” and the maleness of God. “Inclusive language” should be used to refer to God, it was said, as God was not male or female. Or God was both. It was never clear which it was. Old prayers and hymns were revised to reflect this, and new ones were created. Even the Bible was retranslated. But the results of all this were often awkward and stilted.

What was rarely discussed, however, was who, or what, this God actually is. In other words, Nietzsche’s announcement from over a century ago was not part of the conversation. In debating God’s gender, were we actually talking about anything at all?

“God is dead… and we have killed him.” That second phrase often gets left off. What Nietzsche was referring to was the transition to the modern world. In ancient and medieval times, superhuman divine beings existed in a nearly invisible heavenly realm above the clouds. The three-tiered universe was like a layer cake, a lower realm or “underworld” of the dead and/or hell, earth was the middle layer, and above that was an upper realm called heaven. It was often believed to have several levels of its own, where God, or the gods, and various angelic-type beings all existed.

As I said in my latest video, all this, of course, was swept away by Galileo and his scientific successors. The being called God, or God the Father in Christian terms, disappeared along with God’s abode. How can there be a God if there is no place for God to be? That this is now universally accepted is demonstrated by the fact that no one is breathless waiting for the new Webb telescope, peering further into space than ever before, to discover heaven at the edge of the universe. God the Father has left the building.

The belief in God as a supreme being existing somewhere “out there” is called theism. To not believe in such a God is called a-theism. In American culture, it’s one of the most disreputable labels a person can be given. But that’s because it’s misunderstood to mean not believing in God, when it actually means not believing in the theistic being God-out-there.

Recently, pollsters have expressed confusion about why the decline in religious identity has not been matched by a rise in atheism, which remains in the low single-digits. That’s because many of these people also think atheism means “no god.” In reality, many of them likely are a-theists because they have dropped a belief in a God-out-there. But that doesn’t mean they don’t believe in God.

What do the “spiritual, not religious” believe in then? What are the alternatives to God the Father, to God-out-there? Not to be flippant, but it’s the God-right-here. Such an understanding of God is found around the world and throughout history. In fact, archaeology indicates such a notion of God has been around a lot longer than that of a God-far-off.

Early archaeology and anthropology were dominated by Christian Westerners. We still live with their prejudiced judgments. They scoffed at, what was to them, the primitive and clearly inferior animism and pantheism of prehistoric and indigenous peoples. Yet the notion that God pervades reality and that we live in a sacred, spirit filled world has been the a more common view than theism. Today, contemporary indigenous spirituality is viewed much more positively, often as something modern people can learn from.

There has also been renewed interest in the centuries-long tradition of Christian mysticism. To borrow the title of the popular 17th century mystical work of Brother Andrew, in simple terms mysticism is “the practice of the presence of God.” Mystics (who are present also in Judaism and Islam) generally have little interest in traditional liturgy and theology. They are usually not concerned about achieving forgiveness of their sins, but of knowing God’s presence within and around them, and of being awakened, enlightened, transformed by that experience.

What’s surprising to many is that such a description could also be applied to Jesus. In the gospels, Jesus shows little interest in temple ritual, believing rather in God’s presence within and around him. Unfortunately, the church got the notion that this made Jesus unique because he was the Son of God. Yet the case can be made (and increasingly now is made) that Jesus viewed himself as a child of God, like everyone else. His ministry was demonstrating a life possible for anyone who has been awakened by the Spirit to their true identity.

Today, much of the language of the Bible and traditional religion is too pious and antique for modern ears. Indeed, in the 1960s, the renowned Roman Catholic theologian, Karl Rahner, said the church should stop using the word “God” for fifty years because it had been so abused and misused! What we need to remember is that all words are metaphors and approximations. There is a valuable Buddhist saying that all words and teachings are like a finger pointing at the moon. We too easily get obsessed with the finger, when what we need to be looking at is the moon.

Surprisingly, and significantly, “spirituality “is now in broad use to refer to the experience of the sacred and of mystery in life and in the world. Many teachers and authors of various religious traditions, or of no tradition, commonly use the term to identify this dimension of reality. Spirituality is being seen as a way to reestablish our connection with the natural world and stem our abuse of it. And, being a religiously “neutral” term, spirituality is also providing a new opening for interaction with the sciences, especially psychology and theoretical physics.

Unfortunately, traditional Christianity is largely left behind in all this. The church cannot let go of “the Big Guy upstairs”, with its hymns, prayers, and rituals still directed to this imaginary being somewhere “above” us, imploring his forgiveness for our misdeeds and intervention in our many problems. While such piety still has some appeal, it is shrinking by the day, as evidenced by the ever-increasing numbers of empty pews.

God the Father has left the building. Yet rather than being dead and gone as Nietzsche assumed, God is increasingly recognized as a sacred spirit, the unifying and energizing dimension of all reality, embodied must fully in human consciousness.

In the biblical story, this spirit brought creation out of chaos and the first human to life. At his baptism, the spirit awakened Jesus to his sacred identity. Knowing this spirit, he taught that the “realm of God” was not a unique place far off somewhere but here and now, within and all around us. Centuries later, that vision may finally be coming to life.

 

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the topic conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support, which covers blog expenses and enables me to keep doing this.

See how they love each other

See how they love each other

One of the more “interesting” personalities on my seminary’s faculty was Paul Swanson, our professor of pastoral care. He understood the pretense common in church life and that people, both lay and clergy, often tried to hide their true personalities in their interactions with each other. In other words, many have a voice in their heads saying, “I can’t let people know who I really am.”

Swanson was once heard to say to someone, “Let’s have a fight and get to know each other.” In other words, he did not see conflict as something to be avoided but as an opportunity for people to achieve a deeper understanding of each other. But as Swanson understood, the ability to engage in constructive conflict requires a personal sense of security. There has to be a belief that who I really am is okay and doesn’t need to be hidden. As a result, I don’t feel threatened when I engage with someone with whom I disagree.

The institutional church does not have that sense of security, nor do many of its members. Church conflicts are rarely constructive. Different opinions and beliefs are not shared but more often hurled at each other. Opposing sides do not get to know each other better but instead push each other further apart. Differences are viewed in black and white terms of “We’re right and you’re wrong.”

Church conflicts have been increasing in response to changing cultural standards and attitudes, especially regarding sex and gender. Just last week, but after years of struggle, the United Methodist Church agreed to drop its prohibitions on gay marriage and clergy. In getting to this point, however, it lost a quarter of its congregations.

The development of modern culture and the subsequent decline of religion, have left the church confused and defensive. For quite a while it was able to bat away like pesky flies the modern ideas that conflicted with its antique views of life and the world. But by the mid-twentieth century that strategy was clearly failing. The church was losing both members and status.

In response, most denominations adopted one of two strategies. One group tried to reconcile with modern beliefs. These churches adopted critical study methods for the Bible and theology. They championed social justice and began moderating rigid viewpoints on sexuality by accepting gender equity, divorce, birth control, and same sex relationships. Such churches viewed themselves as progressive or liberal.

In contrast, another group of churches doubled down on their conservatism. Often more extreme than during the Middle Ages, these churches insisted on the “literal truth” of the Bible, ancient doctrines, and moral behavior, especially traditional patriarchal gender roles. They often identified themselves as fundamentalist or evangelical.

In practice, neither group has been very successful in their attempts to redefine themselves. Conservative churches have often found it necessary to modify their rigid viewpoints. Divorce was one of the first of these, the result of changing popular attitudes and the divorces of a number of prominent evangelical pastors.

Women’s roles in the church are an ongoing source of controversy. The more progressive attitudes of younger members on environmental issues and inclusion of LGBTQ people is also roiling many conservative churches. The traditionalist ideal, in other words, keeps colliding with the real world in which church members live, with traditionalism often the loser.

On the other hand, progressive churches’ attempts to reconcile with modern culture have often seemed like creating a pushmi-pullyu religion, heading in multiple directions at once. How traditional is too traditional? How progressive is too progressive? These churches are never able to clearly answer to such questions because they don’t really know where they are trying to end up.

Christian verbiage like gospel, salvation, mission, etc. continue to be bandied about but their meaning, especially in contrast with fundamentalism, is never clear. Ask an evangelical pastor what is the “good news” and you will get a one or two sentence answer. As a progressive pastor and you will get a multi-paragraph discourse—and you will often still feel unsure what the answer was.

But the simplicity of the evangelical answer is not any more coherent than the typical progressive Christian’s rambling. Both groups use age-old ideas and language based in a pre-modern worldview that hide more than they reveal. How is going to heaven when we die “good news” if the modern church, in contrast to the ancient or medieval one, can give heaven no meaningful location or content?

Since the 18th century, a growing number of biblical scholars and theologians began tackling the issues raised by the obvious disconnect between traditional Christian beliefs and the developing modern worldview. Their ideas have not been welcomed by church authorities. After outright opposition and even persecution ended, the church shifted to honoring their work while politely ignoring their obvious, and challenging, implications.

Such treatment of recent figures like Paul Tillich (Protestant, d. 1965) and Hans Kung (Roman Catholic, d. 2021) has essentially led to the end of theology as a serious endeavor in the church. Critical biblical scholarship, meanwhile, is increasingly conducted at secular institutions and universities. So, to be simplistic, conservative Christians have stuck their heads in the sand, while progressives are wandering in the desert without a compass.

What’s to be done? What many people are doing is leaving the church altogether, or declining to join in the first place. Being friendly and having good cake and coffee after worship is obviously no strategy for addressing this. It isn’t church style that needs fixing; the church has a content problem. Borrowing Getrude Stein’s dissing of Oakland, her hometown, for the church today “there’s no there there.”

Institutionally, there seems to be no answer. Both conservative and progressive churches are stuck in endless rhetorical and ideological loops. And that is why I thought of Professor Swanson. Since fighting over who’s right or wrong on these issues hasn’t gotten us anywhere, why not try fighting to get to know each other?

The polarizing and demonizing of opposing sides have become a plague in our culture. How sad that churches have so easily succumbed to this divisiveness. How can we turn down the heat and the rhetoric?

Not by “clarifying the issues” since people aren’t listening to each other. Nor will it happen at the organizational level because denominations and their leaders are too frightened about their future. Instead, churches need to come to the awareness that, above everything else, they are communities of people centered on love.

In truth, most congregations are centered on other things: doctrines, leaders, worship practices, property, prestige, social causes, etc. Today people “shop” for churches and most members would say, “I wouldn’t belong to this church if it didn’t have ______.” As they are, churches are destined to polarize and fragment because what they are centered on is unstable and changing. That’s been the experience for most of church history.

Yet that’s not the way it started out. Tradition says that the early Christians were mocked with the saying, “See how much they love each other.” Paul’s famous testament to love in 1 Corinthians 13 was in direct response to divisiveness that had split that congregation. But the centrality of love in the early church’s life is clearest in Jesus’ discourse on love in the gospel of John: “This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you.”

Such a reorientation would be no easy task. Frankly, it would be a revolution. But isn’t that what Jesus intended? As the French Catholic reformer Alfred Loisy said, “Jesus announced the kingdom, and it is the Church that came.” (Loisy was eventually excommunicated.) Recently, I heard a video blogger ask, “Is love a religion?” Since Jesus showed little interest in religion, yet love was at the center of his ministry, that question deserves some long, hard thought.

The end of heroes

The end of heroes

Artist Louise Giovanelli with her paintingEven though I’m still an atheist, I’ve come back to religion, in the sense that I think it’s very important. I’m very interested in the aesthetic of it, and the stories and meaning behind it. I realize now that I’m very steeped in it. It has affected all of my art.

These are the words of Louise Giovanelli, a young, up-and-coming British painter, featured in a recent New York Times article. Raised in a church-going Irish and Italian Catholic family, Giovanelli says she abandoned her faith as an early teenager. When still required to worship with her family, Giovanelli asserted her disbelief by carrying with her into church a copy of The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins.

One of the most common subjects of Giovanelli’s paintings are movie and music stars. Her style, however, is influenced by the paintings of the Renaissance. So, too, is her subject matter. While Renaissance painters typically depicted saints and biblical characters, Giovanelli says her subjects are modern day icons.

What I’m trying to do is draw connections between the ancient and the contemporary…. I’m trying to show the viewer: You still need this type of worship. You don’t realize that you do, but these are the contemporary churches. Instagram and TikTok are a new type of shrine.

The pop stars and new icons in my paintings are the same as looking at icons in a church. I think this is why people like my work: I’ve tapped into that need, the same longing that humans have always had and will always have for the higher being, the perfect being, idol worship and light and glitz and glamour.

I think Giovanelli is on to something. First, we should remember that Renaissance painters were not interested in historical accuracy. Typically, their subjects were portrayed in contemporary Italian scenery and dress, rather than ancient biblical ones. Their characters were also attractive. The portrayal of a female figure (like Mary) could be a beautiful member of the artist’s community, or the wife (or mistress) of his patron. And millions still flock to ogle the amazing (and naked) physique of Michelangelo’s monumental sculpture in Florence of the young David preparing to slay Goliath.

For well over a century, fascination, and sometimes obsession, with secular celebrities of all types has been a hallmark of modern culture. While heroes have been celebrated throughout history, hero “worship” is a recent phenomenon.

Ancient heroes (often mythological) got their status through dramatic acts of courage and sacrifice. Modern heroes, however, usually have no such accomplishments. Instead, they are public figures of exceptional beauty or talent. Actors, musicians, and sports stars make of the vast majority. Recently lifestyle influencers have joined their ranks, usually because of their wealth or their ability to master the intricacies and mysteries of social media. They’re famous for being famous.

It’s no coincidence that celebrities began stealing our attention at the same time that religion was heading into a steep decline. This is what Giovanelli has picked up on. As she says above, “I’m trying to show the viewer: You still need this type of worship.” We have a “longing … for the higher … perfect being.”

Giovanelli here does not delve into why this is so, but perhaps it is obvious. Unlike animals guided primarily by instinct, we need some kind of outside direction for how we should live. Family and community are usually the primary sources of guidance but often this is not enough, or even a hindrance if it is too oppressive. The tales of heroes lift our sights, give us a higher calling to do and be something greater than we would otherwise imagine.

In the Christian era, saints served this function. As religion faded, political and military heroes became the first modern icons of inspiration but this was short lived. Democracy’s stars were too human and their accomplishments too mundane to generate the aura people wanted. Most, like politicians or generals, just faded away. Others rose high but then crashed and burned, like a Napoleon or Hitler. In general, the modern era’s unending cycle of warfare and economic upheaval make political leaders poor candidates for icon status.

Yet today’s pop icons, too, are strange successors in this ancient lineage. I still remember being shocked the first time I heard teenagers being asked about their aspirations and the most common answer was “to be famous.” Not famous for anything in particular—just being famous.

Celebrityhood, like ancient sainthood, has become a quality of its own. If we can’t be famous ourselves, we can attach ourselves to those who are and somehow share in their status. We can dress like them, follow the minutiae of their lives, see them in person, get their autograph, or even better get a selfie with them. Anything to somehow touch their glory.

Of course, celebrities can also crash and burn, sometimes quite spectacularly. Others just slowly disappear. In any case, few maintain their status for more than a generation or two (try to find a Rudolph Valentino or Greta Garbo fan club today). Fans mourn their loss but then move on to new celebrities or somehow enshrine their memory to keep them symbolically alive (Elvis!)

The saints and mythic heroes of the ancient world embodied culture’s deepest values. Do celebrities do that for us? If so, then it would seem our values are not very deep. One of the early TV shows to celebrate celebrities got its title just right: “Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous.” It was not their actual lives that mattered. It was the glitz and glamour of how they lived that attracted viewers’ attention and adulation.

Today’s cultural icons all have, like the book of Daniel’s vision of a great statue, feet of clay. They don’t, and can’t, live up to people’s expectations of them. Often, they are more anti-hero than hero, rebelling against social norms but without any clear purpose. And so, we shuffle through them with amazing rapidity. Everyone, it seems, gets their fifteen minutes of fame.

What all of this points to is that the time of saints and heroes is past. The icons of the ancient and medieval worlds, whatever their value, were nonetheless always imaginary. No one actually knew them. That worked in the small worlds in which most people then lived. But with modern travel and communication, our worlds have exploded. We can be anywhere and see everything. We know too much for any icon to survive for long.

And that’s okay because we really don’t need them. Today we are finally hearing an ancient teaching which at the time mostly fell on deaf ears. And that is, that we already have within us the wisdom and goodness we need to live our lives to the fullest. We don’t need to emulate someone else but learn to listen to and trust the voice inside us. This is our true self, found only in our inner silence. This is in contrast with the self constructed out of cultural expectations, which is in near constant turmoil and is the source of the cacophony of voices in our heads.

This is what Jesus means, in harmony with this tradition, when he says, “The kingdom of God is within you.” It is why he repeatedly tells people, “Your faith has saved you.” It is what Paul means when he says he has discovered that, “It is no longer I (the ego) who live but Christ (the divine) who lives within me.” We don’t need icons to imitate or oracles to obey. We need only to believe what it says in the very first chapter of the Bible, that we have all been created good, and that our life is, in fact, the eternal divine spirit within us.

 

Thanks for reading! Please consider leaving a comment below to be part of a conversation on this post and/or click “Like” if you are so inclined.