Browsed by
Month: July 2025

One eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love

One eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love

Photo of a human eyeMy post-surgical brain fog continues, though now more episodically. Several times I struggled to grind out a paragraph of this post and then lost the energy to go further. I’ve also found myself reading the same paragraph of a book or article multiple times and then giving up. I’ve talked with a few people who’ve had similar experiences and lingering anesthesia is the popular culprit. Apparently it can take months to fully clear your system. Plus, I know the healing process is a whole body effort with the resulting necessary downtime. So I hope all this provides some explanation for my delayed posting and that I’ll be back on a more productive schedule soon. Thanks again for reading! 

Near the end of my last blog post, I said that our notion of God is changing. That we are finding it hard to believe in God as a kind of celestial “help line,” granting our desires and rescuing us from calamity. We are experiencing

… the gradual abandonment of what some have called the “mythic God.” That is, God as essentially an inflated and overwhelming human being, existing in some far-off realm, watching over the events of humanity and the universe. The man behind the curtain, in other words. While at times we may all wish for a special invisible magical friend, today it seems that few of us anymore can take such a notion seriously.

What this really means is the end of the idea of God as a person. For anyone raised in Christianity or any other theistic religion, this is very difficult to hear. This is the punch in the face delivered by Friedrich Nietzsche’s famous 1880s declaration that “God is dead.” In response to this realization, people typically jump to conclusions like life has no meaning, the universe is purposeless, there is no right or wrong, and other nihilistic assumptions. But none of these ideas are necessary and there are strong and ancient nontheistic traditions that view existence otherwise.

But first, we need to get the God-as-person idea out of our system. God is not an inflated version of us, nor, conversely, are we deflated versions of God. History overflows with evidence that viewing God as a bigger version of ourselves has always been problematic. Such a God often becomes the excuse for our worst behavior and the source of unending suffering and disaster. As the Nobel laureate physicist Steven Weinberg said, “With or without religion, good people can behave well and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil – that takes religion.”

To push this to its inevitable and for many the most upsetting conclusion, God doesn’t think about us, judge us, care about us, have opinions about us, or tell us what to do or not do. God does not reward or punish us. God is not a religious version of Santa Claus, checking his list to see who’s been naughty or nice. Freud and others are basically right: our ideas about God are often essentially projections of our parents into an ethereal realm, for better or for worse.

This subconscious God has hung on tenaciously, even though science demolished any literal meaning to it long ago. Where in our unimaginably vast universe could a personal God possibly be? Is anyone really waiting for one of the new amazing telescopes to find him? The only alternative is to create fantasies of other places or dimensions which have no basis in experience or even in religious tradition. While in times of need or distress we may be able to cling to such an idea of God, over the long haul it provides no support or guidance to life as we actually live it today.

Many of us have distorted and dismissive notions about the ancient religions of the world. In Sunday School we learned about their silliness in believing in multiple gods and idols of wood and stone, in contrast to the Bible’s supposedly obvious truth that there is only one, invisible God. In fact, ancient people were far more sophisticated than we give them credit for. They understood that their gods were characters in stories which helped make sense of life and the world, and how to relate to them. But these gods were actually pointers to a divine reality which transcended them and the universe but which was ultimately unknowable.

The unknowability of God is, of course, a fundamental teaching of the Bible but one usually ignored by religious teachers, preachers, and ordinary believers who have so much to say on the matter. This is a central theme of Wisdom books like Job and Ecclesiastes, but it’s also present from the beginning in the mystery of creation and in God’s dealing with Abraham. The awareness that “no one can see God and live” echoes throughout the Bible.

But the personhood of God has a more fundamental problem than conflict with science or religious tradition. The reason God isn’t a person is because we aren’t either. The egoic self we imagine ourselves to be is an illusion. The ego is the creation of our minds to provide ownership for our thoughts, feelings, hopes, fears, intentions, plans, and presumed destiny. You’ll have as much luck finding yourself somewhere inside you, as you will finding God somewhere out there. There is no little being inside our head peering through our eyes, pushing buttons and pulling levers, and generating our thoughts and feelings.

This egoic fantasy is what we have inflated and projected outward as God Almighty, living in an equally imaginary transcendent realm called Heaven. It was out of the insecurity of our ego that we produced a Supreme Ego to protect us and calm our anxieties. In other words, we can’t figure God out until we figure ourselves out. Our distorted view of ourselves will inevitably lead to a distorted view of God.

Socrates is supposed to have taught, “To know thyself is the beginning of wisdom.” And the instruction “Know thyself” was inscribed over the entrance to the Temple of Apollo at Delphi. An ancient and fundamental spiritual practice of many traditions is called “self-inquiry.” All of these point to the most basic human question: Who am I? This is not an intellectual pursuit, however, but an inner search, an experience leading to a deep knowing of our true identity.

Contrary to many wellness coaches or corporate programs, this is the actual purpose of meditation. We sit and focus our attention inward not to create silence but to discover the silence that is already there, the nature of our very being and our true self. From within that silence, we listen to and observe all experience: the natural world around us, including our own bodies, and the thoughts and feelings streaming through our minds. As we continue in this practice, we come to the realization that our true self is not any of these sensations but that which observes them, our aware consciousness. And as we go further, we discover this is also the intersection point of the divine reality we call God.

Attempting to overcome the misconceptions of his time, Jesus introduced the notion of the “kingdom of God.” It was mostly misunderstood, including by his own disciples and the gospel writers. But occasionally his intention and meaning sneaks through, as in a remarkable passage in Luke 17. When asked when God’s kingdom was coming, Jesus rejects the very idea. It’s not coming with signs to watch for, he says, because “the kingdom of God is within you.”

This awareness has been most prevalent among the mystics of all religious traditions. The great Muslim poet and Sufi mystic, Rumi, said, “I searched for God and found only myself and I searched for myself and found only God.” Among Christians, it is the medieval theologian mystic, Meister Eckhart, who I quote often, who has provided the clearest and most powerful teaching on our oneness with God.

The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.

This also explains one of Eckhart’s most astonishing quotes, “I pray God to rid me of God.” That is, he wants to get rid of all notions of a theistic God-out-there to know only the inner yet transcendent God who does not “exist” like any object but is rather “the ground of being.” Here we connect with a remarkable statement in the book of Acts that’s attributed to Paul, that God is “the one in whom we live and move and have our being.” Which points to the paradoxical truth that God in us, and our being in God, are one and the same reality.

One could spend a lifetime trying to make sense of all this, but that isn’t the point. Again, the mystics are our guide, for their words are intended not to fill our minds with ideas but to point us to a knowing experience. And if religion is to regain its value this is what it must be about: not pointing us out of this world to some imagined heavenly dimension but rather deeper and more profoundly into this world. For we need a new (but actually ancient) recognition of the sacredness of Being itself, permeating all reality, the entire universe, and each one of us. And by knowing our own sacred identity, we will then know what Paul called “the peace that surpasses all understanding.”

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this.

When the floodgates won’t close

When the floodgates won’t close

Photo of water pouring through a floodgateThe gods of the ancient world tended to be practical and accessible. They were not always predictable, however, and could even be capricious at times. The multiplicity of gods represented the complexity of life and of an uncontrollable world. Their names and characteristics varied from place to place, but it was nearly universally true that gods were appealed to in various ways to perform tasks that humans needed to have done.

A list of such needs, of course, was endless, as seemingly was the number and names of gods to perform them. They could, however, be fairly easily categorized based on the primary needs and predicaments of human life. Thus, people prayed and sacrificed to one god or another for rain for crops, for help in getting pregnant, for healing from disease, for good hunting, for protection from natural disaster, and so on.

As cultures and life got more sophisticated and complicated, so too did the gods and the needs that people brought to them. One could ask for help in getting someone to fall in love with you or for a curse on a personal enemy. And gods became nationalized, granting protection from enemy tribes or countries and giving victory in battle.

The Bible appeared on the scene in this more complicated phase. What sets it apart, however, is its insistence that there is, in fact, only one God. Remnants of the multiple gods view are still present in it, especially where foreign peoples are understood to have different gods. Some more ancient texts accept that this is actually the case. Later, these foreign gods are dismissed as fakes. Wisdom, the Bible teaches, is coming to know that there is only one universal God, the LORD, rendered as YHWH in the manuscripts (more a symbol that a word).

What was unclear, however, was whether the Lord could be appealed to for personal and other needs in the same way the earlier gods could be. Evidence of this uncertainty is in the now common finding of totems and idols of neighboring people’s gods in excavated ancient Israelite settlements. Clearly, practical people took the attitude of keeping all bases covered, though the biblical texts express repeated outrage at such infidelity.

Yet, to be honest, the Lord’s biblical reputation in this department is pretty spotty. Sometimes prayers got answered but often they didn’t. Worse, the Lord often is Israel’s nemesis and causes as much suffering as he resolves. The problem was something called the Lord’s righteousness. This God wasn’t interested so much in the right prayers and offerings as he was in proper behavior, especially from Israel’s rulers.

When we come to Jesus and the New Testament, Israel has become a vassal state and the Lord’s concern with it is less than clear. Is he going to send a messiah to liberate it or has he moved on to more universal, and at the same time, more personal concerns? Jesus, or more accurately his later interpreters, seems to want it both ways. But it’s not long before concern for Israel falls by the wayside (especially after Rome basically obliterates it) and Jesus become a universal savior.

But what kind of savior is Jesus? The numerous healing and other miracle stories depict Jesus as being intensely concerned with people’s individual needs. And writings from Christianity’s first centuries show that this aspect of Jesus remained important and popular. But gradually, Jesus as a divine source meeting personal needs in this life gave way to Jesus as the savior granting something called “eternal life” in a time to come. This is the Jesus we meet in the letters of Paul and the gospel of John. This Jesus as universal Savior and Lord is made the official one in the 4th century at the council of Nicaea (whose creed makes no mention of his earthly ministry).

While Jesus’ intimacy stands out in the gospels, Jesus the resurrected Lord gradually became ever lofty, distant, and unapproachable. In response, the Christian pantheon began to expand. The Virgin Mary became a sympathetic figure who could be appealed to as an intercessor with her son. Since miracles are attributed to the disciples in Acts, people began praying to them to do such things from their positions in the heavenly community. The company of saints expanded as more recent heroic figures were added and many, like the ancient gods, became associated with various specific needs and causes.

As the centuries went by, the Lord God, supported by his heavenly retinue, continued to be viewed as a source of help with the vicissitudes of life. Eternal life in heaven was all well and good but one’s needs and sufferings right now were what held people’s attention.

All this changed dramatically, of course, with the coming of the modern era. The mysterious and seemingly random sufferings visited upon people were gradually given logical explanations. Diseases became explainable in theory and increasingly treatable in practice. In most cases, natural disasters (hurricanes, earthquakes, droughts) still can’t be prevented but are understood and not seen as random acts of divine or malevolent forces.

Christianity was knocked on its heals by all this and still struggles to know how to respond. After its initial attempts to oppose scientific understanding fell flat, it has essentially adopted a have your cake and eat it too posture. Scientific explanations of natural phenomena are mostly accepted yet there are still attempts to give God some kind of role in them. Even the most ardent fundamentalist will go to a doctor but also ask their congregation to pray for them if they are ill. They will check their weather app before going on a picnic and pray for God to give them sunshine.

In the days after the July 4 Texas flood disaster, a few stories appeared about how area churches responded. A minister of a (typically conservative) Church of Christ congregation prayed (with the odd directiveness of some evangelicals), “Lord, turn off the floodgates of heaven right now.” Mostly, however, he simply acknowledged the pain and confusion his congregants were experiencing.

At a neighboring mainline Presbyterian church, people were urged to comfort each other and the many instances of people coming forward to help those in need was highlighted. To those who had experienced personal loss, a minister said, “Your pain is seen, your grief is honored, and your questions are valid. We don’t know why this tragedy happened, but we do know this: God is with us.”

Another story focused on a prayer service at an Episcopal church further away in Dallas but which had many connections to the devastated girls’ camp. Here, too, God’s presence was emphasized.

“This service is meant to be that safe, calm space where we come together to be reminded of God’s presence,” said the Rev. Dr. Christopher D. Girata in his opening remarks. Together, the congregation read Psalm 23: “Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me.”

In an interview after the service, Father Girata shared his view of the Christian response to such tragedies.

There’s a saying people like to attribute to Christian theology, which is “God will never give you more than you can handle.” It’s terrible theology. Actually, the entire point of Christ is that we cannot handle the pain of this world. Jesus carries the pain that is too much for us to bear.

I don’t know how representative these examples are, but I suspect they are evidence for a pretty dramatic shift away from belief in what I sometimes call the “cavalry God” who will rush to the rescue of those in distress. Even the minster who asked God to turn off the celestial spigots would have been stunned if, in fact, the rain had ended and the sun came out. His prayer was a remnant of a more credulous past but mostly was an expression of the sincere frustrations of his grieving congregation: Enough already.

Grief is clearly what these services were about. When disaster strikes, people naturally turn to each other for support. Shared grief is much easier to bear and such occasions are where religious communities shine. The millions who attended or watched Princess Diana’s funeral in 1997, followed a few years later by the surge in church attendance after the 9/11 attacks, are two of the most dramatic recent expressions of this human need.

The breakdown of the cavalry God belief system is not simply because of science. Even more it is the gradual abandonment of what some have called the “mythic God.” That is, God as essentially an inflated and overwhelming human being, existing in some far-off realm, watching over the events of humanity and the universe. The man behind the curtain, in other words. While at times we may all wish for a special invisible magical friend, today it seems that few of us anymore can take such a notion seriously.

Who or what is God then? Or is it a notion that just needs to be abandoned finally, like Santa or the tooth fairy? In its early centuries, the church decided to make Jesus the bridge (pontes, Latin for bridge, hence pontiff, pope) between the human realm and the heavenly one. Yet there is no evidence Jesus of Nazareth ever held such a view.

Instead, Jesus seemed to believe there was no gap needing to be bridged. For him, what he called the kingdom of God was all around us and within us. We just need to wake up to see it. Which is why, in saner moments, later theologians would say things like “God is nearer to us than we are to ourselves” (Augustine) and “the eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me” (Meister Eckhart). And later, echoing Eckhart, Paul Tillich would say that God is not a being but rather the ground of Being itself.

Personal tragedy and community disaster throw us into a tailspin, causing us to doubt our self-worth and life’s meaning and value. When we come together, hearing things like “God is with you” may sound trite. But gathering in grief is a way of reassuring ourselves of the eternal Being we all share and which transcends whatever pain and loss we have experienced.

Science has helped explain many of the fundamental principles and laws by which the universe operates. At the same time, however, it has also shown that the universe which we actually experience is the result of a seeming anti-principle: randomness and chance. That randomness produces amazing wonder and beauty but also equally incredible destruction and disaster. We ourselves are the result of the unending interplay of order and disorder, as is everything around us.

And holding it all together is what historically people have called God. You many prefer another word. But whatever it’s called, this primal Reality is the assurance and the deep knowing that, whatever the circumstances, everything is and will always be held together. Trusting in that is what Jesus called “faith” and it yields the experience which Paul described as “the peace which transcends all understanding.”

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this.

Falling apart

Falling apart

Photo of autumn leaves on trees and on the groundRecently, I listened to an excerpt of a talk by the inimitable Alan Watts (1915-1973). Only half in jest, Watts called himself a “spiritual entertainer,” but he was a very smart man and a profound thinker. Watts, an Anglo-American, was an ordained Episcopal priest, but was a student of all religions and went a long way towards familiarizing American audiences with the great Asian religious and spiritual traditions. Thanks to YouTube and podcasts, he is probably better known today than during his lifetime.

In this talk, Watts addressed the preeminent topic of all religion, dying and death. He says we make too much fuss about them because we’re not paying attention. If we did, our attitude would shift dramatically.

So then, we need to see death and its allied phenomena in its “suchness.” That is to say, it is just that after a certain time, as the leaves in the fall disintegrate and fall off the trees, and we say well what a lovely Autumn it was, this New England breeze, a very gorgeous season.

So, in the same way human beings fall apart. And, well, we say that’s terrible. But supposing the unanimity of the social attitude was quite different, and there is no reason why it shouldn’t be. And falling apart is considered quite the thing to do. After all it helps to clean things up. It gets old stuff out of the way and so we, us, I can all go on. We renew, we come back.

And so, the whole thing you see is this: You can’t suddenly switch from death as an awful horror to death as a great event. You have to go through a certain intermediate point, where you have to see it, … that this is very useful.

As you probably know, I have recently been having my own experience of “falling apart” of a bio-mechanical nature. For unknown reasons, except what Watts alludes to above, my hip joint became increasingly nonfunctional and so, I had it replaced. Slowly, and somewhat painfully, my body is integrating and adjusting to this new reality.

This comes after many years of dental fillings, eye glasses, lens replacements via cataract surgery, and a dental implant. All in response to this tendency of my body to fall apart. And who knows what more lies ahead. Except I can be sure that, again to use Watts’ language, eventually my “leaf will fall off the tree.” How awful. But is it, really?

As Watts says, things being born, maturing, and dying are all around us. It’s what the natural world is all about. It can’t be any other way. Yet, in our case we think this is wrong somehow, and therefore a source of great sorrow. So, Watts asks, why don’t we save ourselves a lot of distress and emotional turmoil by changing our attitude and decide that “falling apart is … quite the thing to do”?

Watts, of course, knows the answer. The obstacle to adopting such a logical attitude is our sense of self, this thing called our “ego.” But our ego, according to Watts in another talk, is a “hallucination.” It’s a collection in our mind of countless ideas and images of our ourself, accumulated over our lifetime, often for the benefit of those around us. But it’s not real.

I wonder what you mean when you use the word “I.” What most civilized people mean by that word is a hallucination, an identification of ourselves with our idea of ourselves. Or I would rather say, with our image of ourselves. And that’s the person, or the ego. You play a role. You identify with that role. I play a role. It’s called Alan Watts. But I assure you it’s a mask and I don’t take it seriously. So I know I’m not that.  But most of us are taught to think that we are whom we are called. When you’re a little child and you begin to learn a role and your parents and your peers approve of your being that, they know who you are.

It’s obvious now that as our world careens towards ecological disaster, something must fundamentally change. We will not “invent” our way out of this. Watts sounded an early alarm about what we were doing to the planet and saw unmasking the ego as essential to changing our relationship with the natural world.

We speak of coming into this world and this whole sensation that we are brought up to have of being an island of consciousness locked up in a bag of skin facing outside us a world that is profoundly alien to us in the sense that what is outside me is not me. This sets up a fundamental sensation of hostility and estrangement between ourselves and the so-called external world….

It should be obvious that the human being goes with the rest of the universe, even though we say in popular speech, “I came into this world.” Now it is not true that you came into this world. You came out of it, in the same way as a flower comes out of a plant or a fruit comes out of a tree. And therefore, people are an expression of its energy and of its nature.

Seeing ourselves as part of this world, rather an as alien invaders, is a transformation in our self-awareness. But that’s only possible if we first come to realize that our ego, our mind, is not our true identity, but a false self. What is our true self? This is where language fails for language is the primary tool of the ego for breaking up reality in manageable bits and pieces. But our real self is a manifestation of the one reality.

In the Bible, the true self is called spirit. In Genesis, Adam comes alive when he receives the breath/spirit of God. And all people, when they die, “give up” their spirit for it to return to God (John 19:30). In Hindu tradition, the true self, apart from body and mind, is called Atman, which is a spark of the divine, ultimate reality, Brahman. More recently, some physicists and other scientist have been saying that consciousness is actually the fundamental reality of existence.

But while fascinating and of some value, theological or scientific formulas and speculation are not the portal into this new awareness. Rather, as all the mystical traditions agree, this self-discovery is the consequence of a spiritual awakening which transcends language. A transformation of how we see ourselves and the world around us. An experience beyond mental understanding of the oneness of all reality, including ourselves.

While little appreciated then or since, this is what Jesus is pointing to when he declares that we must lose our life (false self/ego) in order to find it (true self/spirit). And Paul points to his awakening when he declares that “it is not longer I who live but Christ who lives in me,” with Christ understood as the revelation and manifestation of our true nature.

But again, this is not about religion or holy words, though they may be helpful pointers. Rather it is about seeing with new eyes and discovering a world, a universe, a reality that has been hiding in plain sight. A world that is full of endless wonder and mystery and of which we are an integral part. It is what Jesus called the Kingdom of God, which he says is within us and all around us.

So yes, we all fall apart and ultimately flutter to the ground like autumn leaves. But what amazing things happen in the process! And what amazing things follow as “the old stuff gets out of the way,” to use Watts’ words, and unimaginable new things come into being. And somehow through us, the one Self of love and life brings it about and participates in it all through all eternity.

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this.