Beauty in the breaking

Beauty in the breaking

“San Andreas Fault Has Gone Ominously Quiet” warned a recent headline in the Los Angeles Times. “Ominously” quiet? Shouldn’t quiet fault lines be a good thing? Not always, because faults need to move a little from time-to-time, otherwise they move a lot, all at once, and usually with disastrous consequences.

We like to think we stand on terra firma, solid ground, but our planet’s surface is anything but, as earthquakes repeatedly remind us. Earth’s seemingly continuous but relatively thin surface hides innumerable cracks, the edges of tectonic plates moving in all directions, against, over and under other plates. The earth’s surface, like a hardboiled egg that rolled off the counter and hit the floor, is a spiderweb of cracks. The earth is broken, and yet it’s doing just fine because that’s the way it’s always been.

A recent YouTube video describes this reality from a human perspective. “Everything is Broken: The Most Liberating Realization” gives an example used by a 20th century Thai Buddhist teacher. Holding an ordinary drinking glass he says,

“Whenever you use this glass, you should reflect that it’s already broken.  Develop this kind of understanding. Use the glass, look after it until one day it slips out of your hand. Smash. No problem. Why is there no problem? Because you saw its brokenness before it broke.”

This sounds like nonsense, yet it expresses a wisdom found in nearly all the world’s spiritual traditions, including Christianity. It is why Jesus says that anyone who clings to their life will lose it but those who let go of their life will find it. They will find, if you will, the perfectly good egg beneath the cracked shell.

As the video explains, the broken glass metaphor points to a teaching at the center of Buddhism: the impermanence of all things.

The Buddha said that all conditioned things will pass away. Everything that rises will fall down again. Everything that is put together will fall apart. Everything that is born will die. And the suffering, the dukkha, this sense of unsatisfactoriness that we all have, doesn’t come from things changing. That comes from our resistance to the change.

It’s when we tell ourselves, this shouldn’t be this way or this should last longer, this thing shouldn’t have broken. But that is just reality doing what reality does. We cling and we grasp and we build our happiness on these things that are already heading towards their end. The Buddha saw this clearly. Desire and attachment keep us locked in this cycle where we’re constantly reaching for things and grasping and clinging and then suffering when those things end.

Today, the news seems filled with headlines like that one from the LA Times. Signs of impending disasters are everywhere, it seems. Current extreme weather events are just foretastes of worse to come. One misstep and regional wars could become global ones. The high-flying stock market is surely set for a crash. The next pandemic is just around the corner. The four horsemen of the apocalypse, it seems, are ready and waiting to spring out of the barn.

I don’t mean to make fun of any of this. In fact, it’s all quite serious. The question is how we perceive and react to these imminent threats, how we go about living on the world’s many human fault lines. The temptation, of course, is to run, to get away from these disruptions and threats of disaster. The problem with that strategy is that wherever we go, we find we are only back in a new fault zone. The ground under us will only start shaking again.

I came across a review of a book that has been on my “to-be-read” pile for some time. When Things Fall Apart: Heart Advice for Difficult Times is perhaps the most well-known book by Pema Chodron, a renowned American Buddhist teacher and writer. In the review, on an interesting Facebook page called “The Book Therapist,” the writer confesses to disliking very much what Chodron advises but then having a change of heart.

I am going to say something that might sound strange coming from someone about to recommend a book. I spent the first thirty pages of this book disagreeing with Pema Chödrön. I was desperately hoping that a Buddhist nun who has spent decades studying the human mind had somehow gotten it wrong. Because what she was saying, in the voice of someone who has clearly made peace with it, was something I was not ready to make peace with.

Here’s the sentence that started the argument. She says the things falling apart in your life are not a malfunction. That the ground was never solid to begin with; you were never actually standing on anything, you’d just gotten remarkably good at not noticing. She says the anxious, ungrounded feeling you’re trying so hard to fix is not a problem to be solved. It’s just what it feels like to be a person, accurately, for once, without the usual padding.

I did not want to hear that. I wanted solutions. I wanted five steps. I wanted someone to hand me the ground back. Pema, gently, yet infuriatingly, refuses. And it took me embarrassingly long to realize that refusal is the entire gift of this book.

This acceptance of inevitable change that Chodron teaches is at the heart of countless spiritual teachers over the ages, along with the inevitable anxiety and suffering that comes when we refuse such acceptance. It is the center of Jesus’ famous teaching in the Sermon on the Mount about the lilies of the field in Matthew 6. Avoid the anxiety about what might happen by living in the here and now. As Jesus says in conclusion:

 “So do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will bring worries of its own. Today’s trouble is enough for today.”

The peace of this acceptance comes only by developing a new relationship with ourselves. By recognizing that our anxieties are triggered by a wounded and frightened ego created in our mind, but which is obscuring our true self which has never been hurt and is always at peace, the peace which Paul says, “surpasses all understanding.” To repeat last week’s quote from Alan Watts, this is the life of faith which transcends the futile search for a false security.

Faith has no preconceptions; it is a plunge into the unknown. Belief clings, but faith lets go.

Living by faith our greatest challenge but it is, Jesus says, the only way to experience real, “eternal,” here-and-now life. It is not, by any means, a life without pain or loss. But however much the ground beneath us shakes, such life somehow recognizes it is not ultimately threatened. We are like the wave reaching the shore: its form ends there, as it must, but its substance continues as the ocean which was always its true nature. Just as it is with glasses.

But what [the] teaching is pointing towards is subtler than just accepting that things change. It is about fully inhabiting that. It’s about really recognizing that things will come to an end, so that when the glass breaks, we are not shattered along with it. The glass is already broken. So, you can use it, you can care for it, you can enjoy it. But when the glass breaks, you can simply think, “Ah yes, that is what glasses do.”

You are probably familiar with the Japanese art form kintsugi, even if you don’t recognize the name. It is the practice of repairing broken pottery with gold. It is an expression of wabi-sabi, a philosophy rooted in Zen Buddhism that finds beauty in the natural, imperfect, and transient nature of life. Rather than hiding the cracks, this method highlights them, treating breakage and repair as a beautiful and valued part of the object’s history.

A kintsugi pot represents not just its own history but acknowledges and embraces the brokenness of reality itself. Cracks don’t need to be hidden, such pottery says. They are an inherent part of us and all things, and breaking is what we and all things do. Yet the gold reminds us that this broken reality has a timeless beauty all its own which it, nor we, will ever lose.

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *