Looking for God in all the wrong places

Looking for God in all the wrong places

From “Creation of Adam” by Michelangelo, Sistine Chapel, 16th c.

In my last post, I said that we are in a time of “do it yourself religion.” We can’t anymore rely on traditional institutional religion for our spiritual wellbeing, so we must take care of it ourselves. There are a couple of obstacles to that happening. One which I mentioned last time, is that it takes time and effort. The other is that we may not feel we have permission.

Most versions of Christianity (like many religions) have a concept of revelation. It assumes that God can’t be known by human beings directly, so God is revealed in the Bible, the sacraments, and through religious authorities. All this is under the auspices of the church. For that reason, in its most extreme formulation, it has been said that “outside the church there is no salvation.” In other words, if you’re going to connect with God, who is presumably the source of salvation, then you’re going to have to do that through the church.

All of this is antiquated now. A divine heavenly authority figure, doling out rewards and punishments, is simply unbelievable. Five hundred years of scientific discovery has, as it’s been said, left the ancient God both homeless and unemployed. In the universe of contemporary cosmology, heaven is nowhere to be found. And scientific theory and law have become the explainers of all of nature’s structures and processes, making superfluous a God pulling the universe’s strings.

More importantly, traditional religion’s God just doesn’t work for us anymore. First, we recognize the image’s origins in both the monarchs of ancient empires and the less-than-healthy models of pre-modern father figures. Further, unending existence in a heavenly amusement park (as Marshall Davis has dubbed the traditional notion of eternal life) doesn’t appeal to us as it may have to our medieval peasant ancestors. In short, the ancient world’s God and what he had to offer have both lost their appeal.

So, end of God? End of story? The nineteenth century’s bad boy philosopher, Friedrich Nietzsche, declared, “God is dead and we have killed him.” As far as he was concerned, it was the end. The God of the ancient world died with that world, thanks to the rise of modernism. And I don’t think it’s wrong to assign some of the blame for modernism’s inhumanity to God’s demise. For that reason, the conservative reaction to God’s “death”, in both religion and politics, is understandable.

But reviving the ancient world’s God is no more reasonable that trying to bring back the ancient world. Not only do we like antibiotics and indoor plumbing too much to give them up, but we are also now modern people. Humanity has changed and is still changing. And I am convinced that, despite the obvious problems we’ve encountered along the way, that change has been for the better. As modern people, we now have the freedom to live lives of our own choosing, and we have permission to find truth for ourselves. The ancient cultural authorities have been dethroned.

So, just as living in a democracy takes more work than living in a monarchy or dictatorship, so too is DYI religion more work than to be the trusting believer in an ancient God. Frankly, one of the things that religion takes advantage of is our laziness. “God? Don’t worry about it. We’ll take care of this for you.” The other thing religion uses is our lack of self-confidence. “I don’t know anything about God. How could I? I better rely on the experts.”

Both attitudes are beneath us and do nothing for us. They both assume God is some being external to us which is impossible for us mere mortals to reach or grasp. That people have such attitudes is understandable because it is what religion has taught them. After all, believing in such a God is what has kept religion in business. But what if this isn’t who or what God is at all?

And at this point, we need to think about this word “God.” I have been using it for convenience, but it has its problems. For people who have left traditional religion, the word God refers to a celestial supreme being, a “Sky God” as it’s been called, that is oppressive and which no longer makes sense to them. Using the word has become an obstacle to a new understanding. For people within religion but open to a new understanding, the same obstacle exists because it is very difficult for us to change a word’s meaning, even if we want to. Say the word “God” and an image or idea from our past will pop into our head, like it or not.

Thus, for many people, God is no longer a useful term. In that context, the medieval mystic Meister Eckhart’s startling declaration makes sense: “I pray God to rid me of God.” For Eckhart, the traditional God-out-there no longer made sense and was an obstacle to his spiritual maturity. For that reason, we need to find a new starting point. Instead of the idea of God passed on from ancient tradition, we need start with what is always most important to us: our own experience.

While it’s not what has been emphasized, knowing the sacred from our own experience is not foreign to the Bible. At the conclusion of the famous story of Moses and the burning bush, the voice simply identifies itself as “I am.” After Job’s encounter with the whirlwind, he declares that his idea of God has been displaced by personal experience: “I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you.”

The New Testament also affirms the intimacy of divine experience. When the disciples ask Jesus to reveal God to them, he responds, “If you have seen me, you have seen the Father.” Paul says his spiritual transformation means, “It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.” Similarly, in Luke and the gospel of Thomas, Jesus declares that rather than being something distant from us, “the kingdom of God is within you.”

In a quote attributed to him in the book of Acts, Paul says God is “the one in whom we live and move and have our being.” Seemingly as an explanation of those words, Augustine declared that “God is nearer to us than we are to ourselves.” And another quote, so popular there is no historical agreement who first said it, says, “God is a circle whose center Is everywhere and whose circumference is nowhere.”

All of these are ways of making the well-known assertion that God is transcendent, omnipresent, unavoidable. But then we ask, “If that’s so, why can’t I find God?” The answer of theologians (including Martin Luther) has been that God hides, which would seem to be impossible. What if, instead, God is hiding in plain view. What if God is hidden only because we haven’t learned how to recognize God, or haven’t realized it was even possible, or were taught it was impossible?

At this point, we run up against the limits of language. But perhaps better, we might say we discover our language is limitless in pointing to this limitless reality. For what we are talking about is that which is the source and union of existence itself, i.e. all things and all of us. Religion, philosophy, science, and poetry have all contributed to this conversation: God, Brahman, Tao, Kingdom, Spirit, One, Mind, Energy, and Love are some of the most common terms.

The term which Meister Eckhart used most often was “Ground of Being,” a phrase that has recently gained new favor. But what sets Eckhart apart from conventional philosophy or theology, is that this notion was for him deeply personal. It wasn’t an idea one thought about but a reality intimately experienced. This is what he is pointing to in his famous quote that I used in my last post.

The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.

For Eckhart, as the Ground of Being, the deepest spiritual truth is that God is one with all things, and therefore one with us. Where do we experience this oneness? In our “eye”, our seeing, our awareness, the consciousness which we experience when our mind falls silent, that which yields our experience of our own being, our “I am-ness.” Again, this doesn’t arise from deep thinking. Quite the opposite. It arises from the deep silence within us, often hidden and drowned out by our thoughts, yet always present. It is here that we “see God”, Eckhart says, and discover there is, in fact, only one seeing.

The Enlightenment philosopher Rene Descartes famously said the first principle of all knowing is “I think, therefore I am” (Cogito, ergo sum). But he was wrong. Prior to thinking is consciousness, our awareness of thinking, feeling, sensing, and of all experience, amd which yields our sense of being, our awareness that “I am.”

For at least a century, science has been trying to understand consciousness. Material science had focused on finding the part or function of the body, presumably something in the brain, that produces consciousness. So far, it’s had no luck. Theoretical science, however, especially physics, has said that’s looking through the wrong end of the telescope. Two of the founders of quantum physics, Max Planck and Erwin Schrödinger, both concluded that consciousness is not an end product but rather where everything starts. Planck stunningly declared,

I regard consciousness as fundamental. I regard matter as derivative from consciousness.

And in Schrödinger’s view:

Consciousness is a singular entity. What we experience as separate individual minds are not genuinely separate at all, but local expressions of a single universal consciousness that underlies the whole of reality.

While not unaware of the implications of their ideas, neither man was writing from a religious perspective. In both cases, their understanding of consciousness grew out of their scientific study. They realized, however, that what they were pointing to was what in the past would have been called God. Though with fits and starts, the supposed antagonists, science and religion, are aiming at the same thing, the ultimate reality from which all existence arises.

By its very nature, consciousness is something we all know. It is how we know. It is accessible to everyone. Thus, to continue using this word, God may be beyond understanding but is not beyond anyone’s knowing or experiencing. To start, Meister Eckhart says, we need to drop all our preconceived ideas about God. Then, prepare to be amazed.

Apprehend God in all things, for God is in all things. Every single creature is full of God and is a book about God. Every creature is a word of God.

But most importantly, God is in us. While often forgotten, this truth is fundamental to Christianity. Jesus prays in John that his followers would all be one with God just as he is. And Paul reminds the Christians in Corinth,

Do you not know that you are God’s temple and that God’s Spirit dwells in you?

The ultimate meaning and purpose of prayer, meditation, contemplation, is to experience and know this “ground of being” within us, this awareness that unites us with all reality. As consciousness, it is the core of our own being, known in the silent peace that is at our center. Eckhart says,

There is a huge silence inside each of us that beckons us into itself, and the recovery of our own silence can begin to teach us the language of heaven. 

In silence, God stops being a “thing” to have ideas about and to argue about (thus the meaninglessness of the poll question, “Do you believe God exists?”). Instead,the notion of God points to what is beyond words yet perhaps expresses for us what is our center, what we experience as our union with all reality, and what gives our life and all existence meaning and value. Returning again and again to that ultimate Truth within us, we come to appreciate who we are, why we are here, and what “this” is all about. We discover that, in the words of Meister Eckhart,

The most important hour is always the present. The most significant person is precisely the one sitting across from you right now. The most necessary work is always love.

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this!

4 thoughts on “Looking for God in all the wrong places”

  1. Here’s a question? Whoever or whatever “God” is, Does God know who or what God is? From a Christian context, the burning bush story comes to mind, “I am who I am.”

    1. This is starting to veer into speculation but there is a long tradition, which I would agree with, that says “Yes.” Namely, that existence, the creation, which includes us, is God’s self-knowing. For that reason, Eckhart says there is “one seeing, one knowing, one love.” We are incarnations of God’s self-knowledge; our consciousness is an expression of God’s consciousness. That’s why the silent awareness we experience in meditation/contemplation is our “meeting ground” with God. The key is to realize that we and God are not two different “things.”

  2. Currently I’m reading Richard Rohr’s “just this.” I highly recommend to all this short book, but not a quick read, for relevant thought and reflection to your most recent blogs, Doug. Rohr makes a case for one to have a contemplative mind, a mind that, ” . . .does not tell us what to see, but teaches us how to see what we behold.” Another voice on this same idea is a “children’s book” called “Noticing,” by Kobi Yamada and illustrated by Elise Hurst. From the inside front cover sleeve, “This is a story about noticing the little things, the grand big things, the imaginary, and sometimes, the hidden things . . . The incredible is everywhere, and in everything–waiting to be known, discovered, recognized. It’s not only what we look at, but how we see it” Now back to Rohr who writes, “Truly great thinkers and cultural creatives take for granted that they have access to a different and larger mind. They recognize that a Divine Flow is already happening and that everyone can plug into it. In all cases, it is a participative kind of knowing, a being known through and not an autonomous knowing.” This idea of a Divine Flow has become more my experience of who and what “God” is–a being of essence and/or an entity, but also a being of presence in the eternal now (Rohr) and seen in events, relationships, experiences, interruptions and surprises that catch my attention which I call synchronicities. And from Lawrence Kushner who calls these very concrete experiences with God “convincing souvenirs of the eternal.” Finally from the comedian and entertainer Jackie Gleason, who was credited with the comment, “How sweet it is!” May it be so . . .

    1. Thanks for those recommendations, Reid. Oddly, I found Just This on my book shelf but it doesn’t seem to have been opened! However, I have read (and recommend) two of Rohr’s longer books on this general theme, The Naked Now and Immortal Diamond. In any case, I think you are echoing a common theme of spirituality that awakening to the sacred also means awakening to the world around us. As I quote Eckhart, “every creature is a book of God.” And the idea of Flow is an important one in the Tao Te Ching. Much of our misery, it says, is from resisting the flow of the Tao in our life. But I especially like this sentence, “In all cases, it is a participative kind of knowing, a being known through and not an autonomous knowing,” which I think echoes what I was saying in my response to your comment above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *