I’m So Glad We Had This Time Together

I’m So Glad We Had This Time Together

I have decided it’s time to step back from this blogging project of mine, at least for a while. I have been writing essays like these, usually in my congregation’s weekly newsletter, for about twenty years. After retiring, I continued my writing by creating this blog. In those 21 months, I enjoyed that writing and was rewarded in doing so, and I know many of you felt the same by reading them. For that I am deeply grateful.

While I continue to enjoy writing, recently I have had the feeling that, at least in this regard, I have pretty much said all I have to say. On several occasions, I have had a blog post idea in mind. But when I looked back at my previous posts and “Reflections” essays, I found I had already covered the topic and didn’t have anything new to add.

With that in mind, I’m going to look at the three main categories of my past writings and briefly summarize what I have been saying and thinking about them: they are church, culture/society, and spirituality. In doing so, I won’t be trying to say anything new but rather state my overall conclusions about them, and in most cases what my views have been for some time.

*  *   *

Church: The church has played an enormously important role for me throughout my life. It was, of course, the center of my professional life. And it increasingly was the source of great frustration. With retirement, I created some distance from the church and found how little interest I have in it anymore. I’ve evolved and moved on but the church hasn’t. Or, if it has moved, it has been in a different direction than mine.

This is, of course, a very common story. As I have written many times, church membership and attendance have been declining for decades. You can find countless videos on YouTube by people explaining their withdrawal from church life, including many by former clergy. In the wake of the pandemic, even thriving congregations often report a permanent drop of 20% or more in their worship attendance. For marginal congregations, such a loss has been unsustainable. Churches have been closing in the US by the thousands every year, with no end to that trend insight.

In recent years, as I have read about churches, listened to clergy, or visited congregations, the well-worn saying comes to mind, “The more things change, the more they stay the same.” Fundamentally, Christianity is an ancient and medieval way of thinking which has never adjusted to the modern world. It’s naïve scriptures and doctrines anchor it in the past. The meaning and power of its symbols have not carried over to this age.

The church’s essential problem is that it can’t explain anymore what being Christian means, let alone why it’s a good thing. The church itself knows this, which is why church life has become so anemic. Aware church leaders often say that, like Jesus, the church must die to be reborn. But that dying will be very real and will take some time. And what it will be reborn as is by no means obvious.

Culture/society: Recently, I found the first newsletter column I had written almost eight years ago for my Florida congregation. The topic was the climate crisis. I could have written it last week, except for one factual element. I quoted a report, new at the time, saying that an industrial era rise of 1.5 degrees C was the upper limit to avoid catastrophe and that it would likely be reached in 12 years. We actually have already surpassed it.

As I wrote a few weeks ago, the climate crisis is the elephant in the room. Everyone sees it but no one wants to talk about it. The much ballyhooed midterm elections are just two months away, yet this topic is the one no candidate will touch. Preachers want to talk wisely about stewardship of our planet but the time for that has past. Now it’s only the voice of the prophet that can speak honestly: disaster is coming and we have brought it upon ourselves. But we all know what happens to prophets.

The unwillingness to be honest about our most crucial issue has resulted in unreality permeating much of our society and culture. Out time is often compared to the crumbling Roman empire or pre-revolutionary France. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer, on a global scale. Though the “lifestyles of the rich and famous” get ever more outlandish and absurd, they are still held up as something we should emulate. Even though it is the single greatest source of our problems, we continue to fight over control of oil. Yet that struggle will likely soon be matched by one over a resource even more fundamental: water.

Of course, this sounds terribly gloomy, and on a large scale it is. But we don’t live our lives on a large scale, only a personal one. In Luke 3, John the Baptist rails at the crowd for their infidelities: “You brood of vipers!” Struck to the core, the people respond, “What, then, should we do?” Rather than lay out a program of national transformation, John responds on an individual level. “Whoever has two coats must share with anyone who has none, and whoever has food must do likewise.” Tax collectors should be honest; soldiers shouldn’t bully. And so on.

In other words, John is saying, you can’t change what happens in the temple or the governor’s mansion or the emperor’s palace, but you can control what happens in your own life. And that’s enough, because how you live your life does make a difference. Jesus, of course, carried on that message.

I recently watched a video by an artist who regularly comments on art and the artist’s life. Brian Rutenberg grew up in South Carolina and since graduating from college has worked in New York City. I had the pleasure of meeting him at his recent art opening here in Santa Fe. For Rutenberg, all art is a struggle and an affirmation that struggle is worthwhile.

A work of art should start with an obstacle so that the spectator doesn’t go straight through to the idea. For example, a dancer must overcome sore muscles and even gravity. A poet pushes against language. A filmmaker grapples with a camera and a composer combats time itself.

For me and you, we must deal with sticky obdurate oil paint. The key is to make the struggle look effortless. That’s why all art is political. The best way to say f-you to suffering and injustice is to make something beautiful and put it into the world. To make something beautiful is to acknowledge pain and the will to rise above it. Art can only be political. Beauty is the ultimate form of protest.

The key, of course, is to realize that each of our lives are works of art. We all have the potential to make of ourselves something beautiful. According to Genesis 2, that’s what God was doing in making the first human and all living things, like a potter, from the earth. And in Genesis 1, God’s first instruction to humanity is “be fruitful”, a wonderfully suggestive notion.

There may be little we can do to affect the ugliness in the world, but there is much we can do to create beauty in and with our own lives. And to help guide and inspire others to do the same. Paint a picture. Plant a garden. Write in a journal. Prepare a dinner party. Dress with flare. You might not realize it, but you are making the world a better place. And that matters. A lot.

Spirituality: I have written about spirituality more than any other subject. It shows up in nearly all my essays. Spirituality is simply the experience of discovering who we truly are. Unfortunately, we are usually given little direction or encouragement in this endeavor. Most institutions we deal with (family, school, religion, government, work, media) would rather tell us who we are than help us find out for ourselves.

Since ancient times, the ones who have tried to help people in this calling (for that’s what it is) have been known as mystics, gurus, sages, and wisdom teachers. I count Jesus among them and, like him, they often got themselves into trouble for their efforts. The fact is that society (whether religious or secular) would much rather control people than set them free.

Who are we? In the terms of Christian spirituality, we are incarnations of God in human form. How could we be anything else? Jesus, then, was not uniquely God incarnate but perhaps the most realized such person, trying to teach everyone that this is their identity. Unity is thus the ultimate truth and not separation and disunity. To cite again my favorite quote of the 14th century mystic, Meister Eckhart:

The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.

Eastern spiritual traditions are less likely to speak of God but, using different words, their teachings are much the same. Again, quoting Meister Eckhart, “Theologians may quarrel, but the mystics of the world speak the same language.” All these traditions agree that it is an imaginary self, created in our mind, our distraught and divided ego, that is the source of our suffering. Awakening is the discovery of this truth and of our true self, which is one with the “Ground of Being.”

And to experience spiritual awakening, all traditions agree that language is often more of a hindrance than a help. For the key to knowing ourselves and the Truth underlying all reality is not words, but silence. Eckhart once more:

There is a huge silence inside each of us that beckons us into itself, and the recovery of our own silence can begin to teach us the language of heaven.

To ask in the silence of meditation, “Who am I?”, can lead to the most profound and transformative experience we’ll know. Doing so, we do not get a verbal answer but a deep knowing beyond words. And with that, a deep and consoling peace “beyond understanding”, as Paul says. Guiding people to know peace, freedom, life, and rebirth are the repeated themes of the New Testament, yet how little attention they have been given during church history. No wonder so many today identify as “spiritual, not religious.”

Yet it is the “shadows” within us, as Carl Jung called them, which obscure our true identity from ourselves and lead to our suffering and alienation. Multiply that experience by the billions and the suffering of our world is no surprise. We can’t deal with the world’s problems until we have first found the source of peace within us. Spirituality isn’t navel gazing or going into hiding, but the practice which transforms the world by first transforming ourselves.

*  *  *

The subtitle of this blog is “Reflection and Conversation about Life, Spirituality, and Religion”, corresponding roughly to the three categories above. What I have written here is the core or underlying principles of pretty much all my posts. I don’t think I have ever blatantly contradicted myself, although my emphasis has likely shifted over time. I hope I have given you enough to ponder that you, too, will continue to wrestle with these issues and be enriched and grow in the process.

I was going to conclude with a list of some of the most important resources that have guided my thinking and writing. They could, perhaps, be of assistance in your own life and spiritual journey. However, I soon realized that this would constitute a post of its own, so I will post that soon as a sort of addendum to this one.

As I said above, I do enjoy writing. So, if circumstances and the stars align, don’t be surprised if a post from me appears from time-to-time. Otherwise for the foreseeable future, my plan is to get back to reading outside the parameters of this blog, get out into nature more, and revive my painting practice. I hope to better live out Brian Rutenberg’s advice above to protest the ugliness of our world by bringing beauty into wherever I can. Or, to use the language of our Navajo neighbors here, to better practice “walking in beauty.”

Thank you for all your support. I look forward to hearing from you from time to time. Your friendships are of great value to me. (And look for the “Resources” post which will follow along soon.)

If you appreciate these posts, remember to “Like”, share, and subscribe, if you haven’t done so already. In the mystical world of search algorithms, this all helps “spread the word.” And add a comment, if you’re so moved, to be part of the conversation. Finally, thank you for your financial support (see the “DONATE” box), which covers blog expenses and helps me to keep doing this!

4 thoughts on “I’m So Glad We Had This Time Together”

  1. Your thoughtful and interesting articles over the years have been most appreciated. Best wishes in your new artistic focus – perhaps taking inspiration from the natural beauty of the Southwest.

    Several years ago, I read a book by someone who perhaps would be considered a modern mystic (Matthew Fox). One of his points, as I understood it, was that ‘letting go’ or ‘turning the page’, moving on to the next, was a desirable spiritual practice. Much of your writing, in the church context, has been along those lines — churches ought to realize it’s no longer 325, or 1517, or even 1970. They ought to start leaving behind what is no longer plausible or helpful (but few do).

    A line in a short essay, “The Fall of the Year”, by the theologian Howard Thurman has resonated with me: “There is the time when there must be a separation of that which has said its say and passes – that which ripens and finds its meaning in sustaining life in other forms. Nothing is lost, nothing disappears; all things belong, each in its way, to a harmony and an order which envelops all, which infuses all.” I hope that when my time comes to set things aside, I too will be able to see it as having been worthwhile (as it certainly was with your career and writing), and as preparation for the next stage.

    1. Thanks, Michael, for your kind thoughts and appropriate reflections. It does feel like the right time to move on to “other things.”

  2. Dear Doug,
    So sad to hear we will not have your knowledge and insights at our finger tips.
    What a joy it has been, over the years, to be part of your Florida sessions and then the so appreciated blogs. I will miss your thoughts so well articulated on many subjects and have found them tied to my thinking time and time again. I have found the experience of “turning the page” an exciting adventure and hope you will as well.
    Thank you again and I look forward to your resources list.
    Blessings,
    Jan Mullaney

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *